Springfield, MO

Opinion: How Greitens was able to fire the state’s education leader

Posted online

This fall, Gov. Eric Greitens mounted a challenge to a major principle of the Missouri Constitution.

It involved his successful efforts to get Missouri Board of Education Commissioner Margie Vandeven fired by a method involving the constitutionally guaranteed independence for a few state departments.

The education commissioner serves at the pleasure of the state Board of Education that is protected by Missouri's Constitution from interference by the governor.

For more than 120 years, there have been federal laws establishing independent federal agencies. But states are different from the federal government in using the constitution — the foundation of the structure of government — to establish independent departments.

In Missouri, these protected departments include Conservation, Transportation and Education. There's even one agency below a department level which the constitution gives independence. It's the University of Missouri Board of Curators, which the constitution grants the unique power of "government." Decades ago, a university president told me he thought that gave the curators power to impose a statewide tax for the university. He was not joking.

These constitutionally protected agencies are governed by boards whose members, once confirmed, serve for fixed terms and cannot be removed without cause.

Over the decades, I've heard rural legislators passionately argue that hunting, fishing and wildlife protection are so fundamental to Missouri they warrant constitutional protection from interference by politicians.

As for the Transportation Department, you need only to look at other states that have suffered from the political intrigues of highway funding to understand the wisdom of the framers of Missouri's Constitution to put that area under constitutional protection.

If you have any doubts, just think about New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie's "bridgegate." Missouri's Constitution assures no governor could do that in our state.

The constitutional protection for education's governing board goes back to the original 1945 constitution. There's even a provision requiring a minimum level of funding for public schools.

But Greitens found a way around the Education Department's independence.

The loophole arises because Missouri's legislature meets only during part of the year. So, for more than six months when the legislature is not in session, the Senate cannot confirm the governor's nominations. In that case, Missouri law provides that a governor's nomination becomes an immediate appointment, which ultimately must be confirmed by the Senate within 30 days after the legislature returns.

Because of delayed nominations and resignations, Greitens got to name five education board members who took office without Senate confirmation. That should have given the governor the five-vote majority on the eight-member board to oust the education commissioner.

But he had to remove two nominees who voiced concerns about hasty action. Under the governor's approach, these appointments pending Senate confirmation did not enjoy job protection.

Another nominee who voted to retain the education commissioner, suddenly quit the day before the education board's second ouster vote and was replaced just hours before the Dec. 1 vote to give Vandeven the boot.

But this story is still developing.

One of the governor's fired appointees has filed suit challenging his dismissal on grounds the governor violated a law protecting education board members from being removed without cause and without a hearing.

It's a case that could invalidate Vandeven's ouster. She has not ruled out returning as education commissioner were that to happen.

But it's also a case that has the potential to address the much broader issue about constitutional independence.

In the meantime, the Senate's Education Committee chair — Gary Romine, R-Farmington — vows to filibuster confirmation of Greitens' appointees who voted to fire the education commissioner.

But I'm not completely sure blocking these nominations can stop the governor because there's no enforceable provision setting a deadline for a governor to submit a nomination to the Senate. That means if Greitens' nominees are not confirmed, the governor could wait until the Senate adjourns in the spring before appointing new education board replacements who then could vote to fire the state's education commissioner.

It makes for a complicated legislative issue next year if Missouri lawmakers want to protect the constitutional independence enjoyed by some agencies.

Phill Brooks is director of the Missouri School of Journalism’s State Government Reporting Program. He has been a statehouse reporter since 1970, making him the dean of the Missouri statehouse press corps, and he manages the multimedia website on state government news, Brooks can be reached at


No comments on this story |
Please log in or register to add your comment
Editors' Pick

Open for Business: Black Sheep A.S.A.P.

Black Sheep A.S.A.P. opened; O’Reilly Development Co. LLC completed the final phase of The Castlewood Senior Living; and Red Tree Church moved.

Most Read
SBJ Live logo
Booked - Passion and Perseverance
Booked - Passion and Perseverance

“Being in higher education, we kind of devour books,” says Carol Taylor, President of Evangel University. She recommends Angela Duckworth’s “Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance.” …

Learn Something about Everything “Try to learn something about everything and everything about something,” says Larissa Warren, an associate with Husch Blackwell and one of Springfield Business Journal’s Trusted Advisers for …
"It wasn't too serious to me..." “It wasn’t a job to me at first. I was just enjoying my time,” says Carolyn Billingsley, Producer and Founder of Carolyn Billingsley Productions. Billingsley started her production company at …
Artful Return on Investment “The arts aren’t just for some people and not for others, they belong to everybody.” says Jane Chu, Chairman of the National Endowment for the Arts. Chu says the arts contribute three-quarters …
Plan for Future Sales Have you followed up on all your potential sales? Scott Hutson, Senior Commercial Account Executive with Mediacom, says you should keep track of all opportunities. When you have downtime, revisit …